“Nonsensical”: USSF Files Motion to Dismiss NASL’s Lawsuit

by on 12 October 2017

The United States Soccer Federation (USSF) has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit filed by the North American Soccer League (NASL), arguing that the league has failed to come up with a plan for how it could comply with Division II standards. On Sept. 19, the NASL filed a federal anti-trust lawsuit against the USSF asking for an injunction to prevent the USSF from stripping Division II status from the NASL.

US Soccer filed its response on Oct. 11 seeking a pre-motion conference with the intent of the suit being dismissed altogether. The letter is the first significant insight for how the USSF seeks to counter the NASL’s claims of a conspiracy between USSF, MLS, and the USL to drive the NASL out of business.

While other leagues like Major League Soccer (Division I) and the United Soccer League (once Division III, now Division II) have flourished in recent years, NASL has declined.

The USSF claims that the NASL was granted waivers from Division II status from its inception with the hope of the league growing. “That has not happened,” the letter states. “In fact, while other leagues like Major League Soccer (Division I) and the United Soccer League (once Division III, now Division II) have flourished in recent years, NASL has declined. Despite multiple chances, NASL has not even come up with a plan for eventual compliance with the Division II standards” (emphasis in original).

Without a plan going forward, the USSF claims that the NASL continued to apply for 2018 Division II status. U.S. Soccer’s Board, however, said “enough is enough” and rejected this application. NASL was given the option to apply for Division III status within 30 days of the Division II announcement, but U.S. Soccer claims this option was “ignored.”

The USSF uses this evidence to turn the case from an anti-trust lawsuit to a case of sour grapes. “[This case] has to do with a flawed league that does not like USSF’s decision,” the letter states.

The letter continues by attempting to poke holes in the claim of “supposed conspiracy” alleged by the NASL, calling the claim “nonsensical.”

The case is expected to be resolved by the end of October. If granted, a pre-motion conference would be held sometime before the end of October deadline.

You can read the letter filed by USSF soccer in its entirety here.

The NASL did not respond to a request for comment.

FiftyFive.One is now on Patreon. Do you like the independent coverage of soccer news from Minnesota and beyond that FiftyFive.One offers? Please consider becoming a patron.

Tags: ,

  • Lenny

    The NASL presented a plan going forward, with 3 clubs imminent for 2018 and bringing them from the 8 this year to 13 clubs for 2018(2 already announced for 2018 plus the 3 imminent one’s. The central time zone is covered in this plan as well with New Orleans one of the clubs coming into NASL. It was denied and they didn’t get more time like the USL to revise and resubmit.

    At the same time USL was told they get more time and came back with a revised plan that claims it will meet D2 standards for 2018, a claim they have made before and failed on for 2017.They will also need at least 4 waivers to meet the professional standards requirements however and likely more for the D2 standards they won’t meet when USSF rules on their application.